Signals Research Group Finds Outdoor Macro RAN Unable to Provide Coverage and Capacity Requirements of Businesses and Public buildings
San Jose,
California, February 25, 2013. SpiderCloud
Wireless, Inc., a leading provider of scalable small cell Enterprise Radio
Access Network (E-RAN) systems to mobile operators, today announced the results
of a research study by Signals Research Group into the utilization of licensed
spectrum in range of in-building environments, including college and enterprise
campuses, high-rise buildings, shopping malls, hotels and airports.The research found that as much as 88% of an
operators licensed spectrum was underutilized in enterprise campus buildings,
while on upper floors of high rise buildings a mobile device could handover as
many as 51 times, due to the constantly fluctuating signal strength between all
the visible cell sites.
The results of the
study reveal the limitations of serving in-building coverage primarily by an
outdoor macro network and that coverage inside does not equate to sufficient
capacity for an ever-growing demand for always-on broadband.With approximately 80 percent of all mobile
voice and data traffic occurring indoors, the in-building mobile data user
consumes a disproportionate amount of network resources, requiring the outdoor
macro network to assign more resources relative to the outdoor mobile device for
a given end-user data rate.
When operators
attempt to use the outdoor macro network to provide in-building coverage and
targeted capacity to a relatively small geographic area, this research shows
that they are falling short.Their
spectrum, which is their most valuable asset and in which theyve invested
billions of dollars, is not only being under-utilized, in some indoor scenarios
isnt being used at all, said Michael Thelander, CEO, Signals Research
Group.However, while there are indoor
coverage and capacity alternatives that give the user a range of ways to obtain
connectivity, the outdoor user has no other means.It is the RAN or nothing.So, by shifting the in-building mobile voice
and data traffic on to an in-building solution, not only is in-building coverage
and capacity improved but there is also a direct impact on the capacity of the
outdoor macro network.
The construction
materials used in a building were also found to have a direct impact on indoor
coverage.Signals Research Group found
that an unintended consequence of material designed to be more energy efficient
was that it was also very effective at blocking RF signals from the
outside.The material is designed to
keep sunlight out and control air temperature by absorbing large amounts of
radiated signals.However, the RF
signals from the outdoor macro RAN were also adversely
affected.
A range of
in-building scenarios were tested by Signals Research Group, including college
and enterprise campuses, high-rise buildings, shopping malls, hotels and
airports.Highlights of the research
results include:
·Enterprise
campus: The utilization
of spectrum can vary immensely between buildings on a single campus site.While in some buildings 100% of available
spectrum was used, SRG found that in other buildings the utilization rate was as
low as just 12%.The combination of lack
of an in-building solution and the construction materials used in the building
all affected the indoor coverage and capacity and this is despite the fact
that one of the buildings housed over 500 employees and was the global HQ for a
universally recognized brand.
·University
campus: In performance
tests conducted on a university campus, on average just 30% of the spectrum was
utilized indoors.On some floors of the
buildings that were tested there was extremely poor or non-existent coverage,
while in other buildings it was nearly 100%.Capacity requirements compounded the issue due to the propensity of
students with smartphones to consume large amounts of data in a concentrated
indoor environment.
·High-rise
building: Sometimes a
building can also have too much coverage.High-rise buildings in particular can be exposed to a large number of
visible cell sites, causing high interference level.Signals Research Group found that just
walking around one floor of a high-rise building could require a mobile device
to handover as many as 51 times, due to the constantly fluctuating signal
strength between all the cells.This has
a direct impact on the performance of the device, significantly impacting
battery life.Furthermore, because the
device is effectively always operating at the end of a constantly changing cell,
throughput is affected in a way that is akin to the cell suffering from limited
capacity.Users in a downtown high-rise
environment therefore share network resources not only with outdoor users, but
also with users in adjacent buildings.
·Hotels: While larger
hotels sometimes have in-building solutions, the experience between hotels was
marked.A San Francisco hotel had a
spectrum utilization of just 38%, in contrast to a Dallas hotel, which hit 61%
spectrum utilization.
Signals Research
Group points out that Wi-Fi is not always an adequate alternative to in-building
cellular coverage and capacity in the hospitality sector as an acceptable
alternative for cellular voice. Voice over Wi-Fi mobility and throughput falls
well below the threshold that signifies a good mobile data experience as soon as
many users are congregated together and connected to the Wi-Fi service.
This research
proves what peoples personal experience of having poor indoor coverage at work
or network congestion at the shopping mall is already telling them the user
experience of in-building coverage and capacity is at best mixed and at worst
practically non-existent, said Ronny Haraldsvik, CMO, SpiderCloud
Wireless.Not only that, but recent
end-user research uncovered that over one third of senior IT managers would be
likely to move to a wireless carrier that could guarantee better indoor mobile
coverage and capacity. This makes for a coverage and capacity
double-whammy.Not only is valuable
spectrum being left underutilized, but it is also directly impacting the
end-user experience and creating opportunities for subscriber
churn.
Scalable Small Cell
Systems for Enterprise Deployments by Mobile Operators
SpiderCloud is the
first company to offer a true multi-mode access system with 3G, LTE/4G and
dual-band Wi-Fi for reliable mobile services indoors for enterprise customers of
any size, called an Enterprise Radio Access Network (E-RAN). The E-RAN system
consists of a Services Node (SCSN) that can control over 100 self-organizing and
multi-access 3G, Wi-Fi and LTE/4G small cells that can be installed in just days
using an enterprise-Ethernet Local Area Network (LAN) as managed service by a
mobile operators network. In addition to providing reliable coverage and
capacity, the E-RAN with the Services Node includes an Applications Programming
Interfaces (API). The API inside the Services Node provides trusted connections
to the Radio Nodes and a logical view into all devices on the E-RAN, to enable
secure services to any mobile device on the network.
The third-party
performance analysis was conducted by Signals Research Group on behalf of
SpiderCloud Wireless. The report is available by request from SpiderCloud
Wireless.
About Signals
Research Group
Signals Research
Group (SRG) offers thought-leading field research and consulting services
covering the wireless telecommunications industry.It is also the publisher of the Signals Ahead
research product.The "no holds barred"
approach to conducting research and analysis means that SRG's first and foremost
objective is to offer differentiated research products and services.Instead of just capturing market data and
analyzing past events, SRG focuses on where the industry will be tomorrow and
the technologies and service offerings that will shape its future and not those
that defined its past (www.signalsresearch.com).
Hackday - Tips, Tricks, OpenData sources, and Developer Resources for Mobile Application Developers - Hackday events are becoming quite common, many local government
agencies embracing the format and opening the doors, and their data
vaults, to local developers, hackers, and those simply looking to mashup
some data. Read on for Tips, Open Data sources, Developer Tools, Mobile
Dev resources and more!
Using QR Codes to Deliver Maps Electronically - cartographers
are tapping into technology in the form of Quick Response Codes (QR
codes) to help promote, sell and deliver maps electronically. Ted
Florence discusses QR codes, what they are and how they are useful for
maps and map producers.
10 Resources To Help You Get Started Programming with Python-
There's no question that if you want a head start in your career as a
GIS Analyst, programmer, or other technology professional that Python
programming is a must. Just look around on twitter, follow some geo
hacks on Google +, check out the developer resources, and attend a
GeoGeek meetup of WhereCamp and you'll hear about python.
58% Use Location-based Apps Despite Privacy Concerns- A telephone poll of 1,000 Americans shows that many people are concerned
about geolocation, which uses data from a computer or mobile device to
identify a physical location
The Really Big List of Mapping, Geo location Mobile developer resources, APIs and Tools - The Mobile Ecosystem... no question that mobile is huge and
the opportunity for developers, in particular, geo developers! There's
loads of developer resources on the web so to help the developer,
here's a listing of just some of the fine dev resources, blogs,
toolsets and more to consider when developing or porting your app to a
smartphone or Tablet.
Mobile Technology Feature - Top 10 Business Apps for Android - Android has become one of the most popular mobile operating systems
in the world due to advanced software, competitive manufacturers, and an
app market that is filled with exciting and useful applications. Read
on for this fine Top 10 List compiled by tech writer, Blake Sanders
ArcGIS.com Mashup Tutorial with Flickr and Foursquare data-
Here's a simple "how to" tutorial on working with the free ArcGIS.com
to easily import KML or RSS data from Flickr and foursquare into ArcGIS
to create your own custom map mashup.
Most Users of Free Photo Apps Say Adding Cool Effects is Most Useful - Adding cool effects
to photos was rated as the most useful thing by more than halfof
consumers surveyed using free online photography services, according to
CatchFree a free
online service that helps people find the best free mobile and web applications
to perform useful tasks.
Flickr GPS Photo Tag Tip - Here's a tip for Flickr users who want to share their GPS information
with their photos. note, in order to do this you'll need to be
capturing photos using a GPS-enabled or GPS-aware camera (see you're
smartphone hardware settings to ensure that GPS or location sharing is
turned "ON)".
Social Location Directory
Do you have a location-aware application, social location service or other location-sensitive service that you'd like to share with us? Please browse this growing directory of Social location Services and feel free to leave a link to your favorite service! See the Directory HERE
Featured Events
Location Business Summit USA - The biggest meeting place for hands on knowledge and networking within
the mobile and location industry. Continuing on from the massive success
of last year’s events in Silicon Valley and Amsterdam, join the biggest
and best companies in the community at the most influential LBS focused
summit in the world. San Jose CA
Wavefront Summits - Wavefront Wireless Summits Week 2013 connects
technology solution providers with global business leaders to
accelerate ideas and market opportunities.
The Underground Guide To The iPhone:
The iPhone is – if I may say so – one of the greatest mobile
revolutions of the past decade. More and more, mobile phones seem to
materialize out of our wildest dreams. Because of the tight integration
of third-party applications, you can do nearly everything with your
device — be it gaming, working, fooling around, and of course phoning.